Child bullying in Ontario can lead to significant legal and financial consequences for parents, as seen in the Unified Insurance v. D.E. case. The court ruled that insurance does not cover intentional acts like bullying, leaving parents liable.
Here’s what happened to the parents of bullies in the recent case of Unified Insurance v. D.E. Parents were sued over their daughter being a bully at school, and unfortunately, their insurance did not cover them, and they were forced to pay out of pocket.
Concerned About Liability for Your Child’s Actions in Ontario?
Contact Us Today
The Story:
Mom and Dad (D & L) had homeowners’ insurance. The policy includes liability coverage if their personal actions cause “unintentional bodily injury or property damage”.
D & L were also the parents of a grade 8 girl who bullied another girl at school. The girl who was bullied suffered ongoing physical and psychological injuries. The parents were sued by the victim and her family for compensation. D & L then turned to their homeowner’s insurance for protection. Unfortunately, their home insurer refused to defend them. D & L were forced to sue for coverage under their policy.
Home Insurance and Bullying:
The Province’s top Court took a detailed look at the wording of both the lawsuit and the insurance policy.
The lawsuit alleged that, among other things, the parents “failed to investigate”, “failed to take steps to remedy”, “failed to take reasonable care to prevent”, “failed to take disciplinary action” and “failed to discharge their duty to prevent the continuous physical and psychological harassment.”
What is negligence? The New Oxford Dictionary of English (Clarendon Press: Oxford, 1998) defines ‘negligence’ as “failure to take proper care over something” (p.1240). The Court of Appeal found that it was obvious that this was what we call a “negligence claim.”
The problem is that the parent’s homeowner policy only provided insurance coverage if the homeowners became liable to pay damages (compensation) because of “unintentional bodily injury.”
Is bullying unintentional? The coverage, unfortunately, stopped here.
The policy also specifically excluded claims arising from the “failure of any person insured by the policy to take steps to prevent sexual, physical, psychological or emotional abuse, molestation or harassment or corporal punishment.”
The Court of Appeal said that the first word of the clause is ‘failure’ which is the core of the definition of ‘negligence” but the wording of the lawsuit against the parents brought the claim squarely within the exclusion of their home insurance policy. There seemed to be a failure on the part of the parents in relation to their daughter’s bullying and the bullying is an intentional act. They were not provided insurance coverage to defend against the lawsuit.
Lalande Personal Injury Lawyers definitely deserve their 5 stars. Many thanks to Matt and Heather, who took over our wrongful death claim after we discovered our original lawyer had done almost nothing on our claim in nearly two years. Due to their diligent efforts, our claim has now been concluded successfully and satisfactorily. We regret now that we had not considered the reviews of former clients when first choosing our original lawyer. It would have saved us so much stress and time if we had believed the reviews and just made Lalande Personal Injury Lawyers our first choice. – Annette Hamilton
What does it mean if your kid is hurting others at school?
The situation is unfortunate. We purchase homeowners insurance as a piece of mind contract to protect our own property and assets as well us to protect us against the perils of liability. If another person is injured or another person’s property is damaged, destroyed, lost or stolen, we want coverage. We want and need our insurance company to step in and help us in a time of need. Unfortunately for these parents insurance coverage was unavailable.
They must now pay out of pocket to defend a lawsuit and risk paying compensation to the injured victim…which could be upwards in the tens of thousands of dollars (it is also not rare to see six figures), depending on the extent of the victim’s injuries, the cost of and the contribution of legal fees to the victim’s lawyer, should that victim be successful in court. If he or she hurts seriously hurts someone then you could be on the hook to defend and, if your minor kid loses the case, to pay compensation out of pocket.
Article FAQs
In most cases, home insurance does not cover child bullying in Ontario, as bullying is typically considered an intentional act, which is excluded from liability coverage under most insurance policies.
In this case, parents were sued for their child’s bullying. The court found that bullying was an intentional act, and the parents’ home insurance did not cover the claim because of the intentional nature of the bullying.
Home insurance often does not help with lawsuits involving child bullying in Ontario, especially if the bullying is seen as intentional. Policies usually only cover unintentional harm.
Negligence occurs when a party fails to take proper care. However, in cases of child bullying, the court found that intentional acts like bullying are not covered by home insurance, even if there is negligence involved.
If insurance is denied, parents could face significant financial consequences, including legal fees and compensation for the victim’s injuries, which can run into tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars in Ontario.